Beginner's guide

So you want to make bagels

Good bagels need only flour, water, salt, yeast and malt, but they're stiffer and chewier than any other bread you'll make. Here's the high-protein flour and barley malt that make the difference, a scale and a few dough tools, what you need to boil and bake, and the books with recipes that work.

By Colin B. · Published November 19, 2026 · Last reviewed November 19, 2026

The 60-second version

If you only buy 3 things to start:

  1. High Gluten Flour — 14 percent protein flour that gives home bagels a real shop chew.
  2. Organic Traditional Barley Malt Syrup — The ingredient that gives bagels their flavor, color and shiny crust.
  3. Good Grips 11 lb Food Scale with Pull-Out Display — Weigh flour and water to the gram so stiff dough comes out the same every time.
Budget total
$35
Typical total
$110
A bag of bread flour, instant yeast, barley malt syrup, a digital scale and a bench scraper come to about $35. Add a spider strainer, a heavy sheet pan, parchment and a bagel book for about $110.

We earn commission when you buy through links on this page, including Amazon. See our affiliate disclosure. Price tiers and budget totals shown above are editorial estimates; actual prices vary.

At a glance

Our top pick in each category

The fastest path through this guide — each best-starter pick by category. Scroll for the budget and upgrade alternatives.

CategoryTop pickPriceWhere to buy
Flour and maltKing ArthurHigh Gluten Flour$ See on Amazon →
YeastSAFInstant Yeast, 1 lb Pouch$ See on Amazon →
Scale and dough toolsOXOGood Grips 11 lb Food Scale with Pull-Out Display$$ See on Amazon →
Boiling and bakingNordic WareNaturals Aluminum Half Sheet Pan$$ See on Amazon →
Before you buy anything

A few things worth knowing first

Use high-protein flour. Bagels need flour with 12.5 to 14 percent protein for their chew. Bread flour works. High-gluten flour is what most bagel shops use. All-purpose flour makes soft, bready bagels.

Weigh everything. Bagel dough is stiff, usually 55 to 60 percent water by weight. A few grams of water changes how it kneads and shapes. A kitchen scale is the one tool that matters most.

Plan for an overnight rest. The best home bagels are shaped, then rested in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours. That slow rest builds flavor and makes them easier to boil without collapsing.

Stiff dough is hard on mixers. A small stand mixer can strain on a big batch. Make 6 to 8 bagels at a time, or knead by hand for 10 minutes. It's good exercise.

The gear

What you actually need

Pile of flour with wheat stalks and a wooden scoop

Photo by Immo Wegmann on Unsplash

Flour and malt

Bagel chew comes from protein. High-gluten flour runs about 14 percent protein and is what most bagel shops use. Bread flour at about 12.7 percent works well too. Barley malt syrup adds a light sweet, malty flavor and helps the crust brown and shine. Use a spoonful in the dough and another in the boiling water. Diastatic malt powder is a different product that helps yeast and browning in small amounts.

High Gluten Flour Best starter
King Arthur

High Gluten Flour

$12.95 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A 14 percent protein flour that's a common choice for New York style bagels. It gives a dense, chewy crumb that bread flour can't quite match. Sold in a home-size bag, so you don't need a 50 lb sack. Sold by Amazon. About $12.95, 4.8 stars from 711 ratings.

What we like

  • High protein for chew
  • Consistent results

What to know

  • Harder to find in stores
Organic Unbleached Bread Flour, 5 lb Budget pick
King Arthur

Organic Unbleached Bread Flour, 5 lb

$7.76 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

At 12.7 percent protein, it makes very good bagels and also works for pizza, sandwich bread and rolls. A good flour to learn on if you don't want a bag of something special. Sold by Amazon. About $7.76, 4.7 stars from 8,668 ratings.

What we like

  • Works for many breads
  • Easy to find

What to know

  • A bit less chewy
Organic Traditional Barley Malt Syrup Specialty pick
Eden Foods

Organic Traditional Barley Malt Syrup

$12.55 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

Thick, dark malt syrup for both the dough and the boil. It gives the classic bagel flavor and a glossy, browned crust. A jar lasts for many batches at a spoonful at a time. Sold by Eden Foods. About $12.55, 4.7 stars from 3,418 ratings.

What we like

  • Classic bagel flavor
  • Lasts many batches

What to know

  • Sticky to measure

Yeast

Instant yeast mixes straight into the flour with no proofing, which is easiest for stiff dough. A 1 lb bag is far cheaper than packets and keeps for months in the freezer in an airtight container. Most bagel recipes use about 1 percent instant yeast by flour weight, or less for a long overnight rest in the fridge.

Instant Yeast, 1 lb Pouch Best starter
SAF

Instant Yeast, 1 lb Pouch

$3.99 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

The instant yeast many bakeries and home bakers use. It's reliable, mixes right into the flour, and a 1 lb bag stored in the freezer lasts a year or more of regular baking. Sold by Amazon. About $3.99, 4.7 stars from 32,914 ratings.

What we like

  • Very reliable
  • Cheap per batch
  • No proofing

What to know

  • Big bag for occasional bakers
Instant Dry Yeast, 16 oz Budget pick
Fleischmann's

Instant Dry Yeast, 16 oz

$7.46 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

The grocery-store brand of instant yeast in a resealable bag. Keep it in the freezer and it lasts for months. A fine choice if SAF is out of stock. Sold by Anucollectionx LLC. About $7.46, 4.7 stars from 1,048 ratings.

What we like

  • Smaller amount
  • Easy to find

What to know

  • Costs more per ounce
Bowls of flour and a kitchen scale on a dark floured counter

Photo by Anshu A on Unsplash

Scale and dough tools

A digital scale is the most useful tool in bagel making. Bagel dough is stiff, and weighing flour and water to the gram keeps it the same every batch. It also lets you divide dough into even 100 to 115 g pieces so bagels bake at the same rate. A bench scraper cuts dough, cleans the counter and lifts sticky pieces. A dough whisk helps mix stiff dough by hand.

Good Grips 11 lb Food Scale with Pull-Out Display Best starter
OXO

Good Grips 11 lb Food Scale with Pull-Out Display

$64.95 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A sturdy scale that reads in grams, with a display that pulls out so a big bowl doesn't block it. The 11 lb limit covers a full batch of dough plus the bowl. Sold by Amazon. About $65, 4.7 stars from 9,014 ratings.

What we like

  • Pull-out display
  • Reads in grams
  • Easy to clean

What to know

  • Bigger than basic scales
Primo Digital Kitchen Scale Budget pick
Escali

Primo Digital Kitchen Scale

$25.00 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A compact, simple scale that reads to 1 gram and has been a home baker favorite for years. Two buttons, a tare function and a long battery life. It fits in a drawer when you are done. Sold by Amazon. About $25, 4.6 stars from 7,431 ratings.

What we like

  • Simple and accurate
  • Small

What to know

  • Display can hide under big bowls
Good Grips Multi-Purpose Scraper and Chopper Specialty pick
OXO

Good Grips Multi-Purpose Scraper and Chopper

$14.97 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A steel bench scraper with ruler marks along the edge. Use it to divide dough, scrape the counter clean, and lift shaped bagels without squashing them. Sold by Amazon. About $14.97, 4.8 stars from 19,094 ratings.

What we like

  • Ruler marks
  • Comfortable handle

What to know

  • Edge is too dull to cut bread

Boiling and baking

You'll boil bagels in a wide pot of water for about 1 minute per side, so you need a spider or slotted spoon to lift them out without deflating them. Then they bake on a heavy sheet pan lined with parchment at about 425 to 450 F. Thin pans warp and burn the bottoms. A baking steel under the pan helps the bottoms brown evenly.

Naturals Aluminum Half Sheet Pan Best starter
Nordic Ware

Naturals Aluminum Half Sheet Pan

$35.00 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A heavy aluminum half sheet that heats evenly and doesn't warp in a hot oven. It holds 8 bagels with room to spare and is the same pan most home bakers use for everything. Sold by Amazon. About $35, 4.7 stars from 35,145 ratings.

What we like

  • Doesn't warp
  • Even browning
  • Holds 8 bagels

What to know

  • Hand wash to keep it bright
Solid Stainless Steel Spider Strainer Budget pick
Hiware

Solid Stainless Steel Spider Strainer

$9.48 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A wide wire basket on a long handle. It lifts boiled bagels out of the pot and lets water drain away, so they stay round and don't tear. Pick a basket 6 inches or wider. Sold by BRILLBOW. About $9.48, 4.8 stars from 31,301 ratings.

What we like

  • Drains fast
  • Long handle

What to know

  • Smaller sizes fit one bagel
Original 14 x 16 Baking Steel Upgrade pick
Baking Steel

Original 14 x 16 Baking Steel

$139.00 as of Nov 19, 2026

Our rating · In Stock

A thick steel plate that stores heat. Set your sheet pan on it, or bake bagels right on it, for darker bottoms and better rise. It also makes very good pizza. Sold by Baking Steel. About $139, 4.5 stars from 609 ratings.

What we like

  • Even, strong heat
  • Great for pizza too

What to know

  • Very heavy
  • Needs seasoning
Going deeper

Your first month of bagel making

Bagels take a little practice, but four batches is enough to get them chewy, shiny and round. Here's a week-by-week plan that starts with a simple same-day batch and ends with overnight bagels and your own toppings.

Tray of freshly baked bagels with sesame and poppy seed toppings
Photo by Vicky Ng on Unsplash

Bagels are a stiff dough, a cold rest, a quick boil and a hot oven. Make the same recipe four weeks in a row and change one thing at a time. Keep notes on weights and times.

Week 1: A same-day batch

Weigh 500 g bread flour, 290 g water, 10 g salt, 5 g instant yeast and 15 g barley malt syrup. Mix and knead for about 10 minutes until smooth. It should feel much stiffer than sandwich bread. Let it rise for an hour, divide into 8 pieces of about 100 g, and shape. Rest 30 minutes, boil 1 minute per side and bake at 450 F for about 20 minutes. They won’t be perfect. That’s the point.

Ball of dough on a floured wooden table with a rolling pin behind it
Photo by ☀️Shine_ Photos on Unsplash

Week 2: Shaping

Try two methods. For the poke method, roll a tight ball, push your thumb through the middle and stretch the hole to about 2 inches. For the rope method, roll a 10 inch rope, wrap it around your hand, overlap the ends under your palm and roll them together on the counter. The rope gives a more even bagel. Keep the dough covered so it doesn’t dry out while you work.

Shaped raw bagels lined up on parchment-covered baking sheets in a rack
Photo by Roll 3d6, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Week 3: The overnight rest and the float test

Shape your bagels, put them on an oiled, parchment-lined pan, cover tightly and refrigerate for 12 to 24 hours. Next morning, drop one in a bowl of cold water. If it floats within about 10 seconds, they’re ready. If not, leave them on the counter and test again every 15 minutes. Boil in water with a spoonful of malt syrup. Expect better flavor and a shinier crust than week 1.

Bagels starting to brown in a pan inside a hot oven
Photo by Andy Luo on Unsplash

Week 4: Toppings

Set out plates of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried onion, coarse salt or everything seasoning. Press each bagel into the toppings right out of the boil, while it’s still wet. Bake seeded side up. Try a few plain ones too, so you can taste the bagel itself. Freeze extras sliced in half the same day for toasting later.

Four seeded bagels on a cooling rack
Photo by Robert Gareth on Unsplash

Need the gear? Our bagel making gear guide covers high-gluten flour, barley malt, instant yeast, scales, bench scrapers, spider strainers, sheet pans and books. You might also like bread baking, sourdough and pizza making.

Save your money

What you don't need yet

Beginners get pressured to buy a lot of stuff that doesn't help them play better. Here's what we'd skip on day one.

  • A commercial mixer — A batch of 8 bagels kneads fine by hand or in a regular stand mixer at low speed.
  • Lye — Lye is for pretzels and is caustic. Bagels get their shine from a malt or baking soda boil.
  • Bagel boards — Wet burlap boards are a Montreal and old New York trick. Parchment on a sheet pan works for home baking.
  • A sourdough starter — Sourdough bagels are great later. Learn on instant yeast so you can tell what changed when something goes wrong.
First week

Your first seven days

A short, real plan to get from gear-on-doorstep to actually playing.

  1. Buy bread flour or high-gluten flour, instant yeast and barley malt syrup. · Buy
  2. Read a tested recipe all the way through and weigh out every ingredient before you start. · Learn
  3. Mix and knead a half batch by hand until the dough is smooth and stiff, about 10 minutes. · Action
  4. Shape 4 bagels with the rope and loop method and rest them in the fridge overnight. · Action
  5. Do the float test, boil for 1 minute per side, and bake at 450 F until deep brown. · Action
FAQ

Common questions

Why do you boil bagels?

Boiling sets the outside before baking. It gelatinizes the surface starch, which gives the shiny, chewy crust and stops the bagel from rising too much in the oven. That's what keeps the inside dense.

What flour is best for bagels?

High-gluten flour around 14 percent protein, like King Arthur Sir Lancelot, gives the chewiest bagel. Bread flour around 12.7 percent is a close second and easier to find. Avoid all-purpose flour.

Do I need barley malt syrup?

It's not strictly needed, but it gives the classic bagel flavor, color and shine. Add a spoonful to the dough and to the boiling water. Honey or brown sugar work as a substitute.

Why are my bagels flat?

They likely over-proofed. Do the float test: drop one bagel in a bowl of water. If it floats within a few seconds, they're ready to boil. If it sinks, give them more time. If they spread before that, shorten the rest.

How do I get the seeds to stick?

Press the bagels into a plate of seeds right after they come out of the boil, while the surface is still wet and sticky. Then put them seeded side up on the pan.

Going further

Where to next

Browse by category

Authoritative sources